Debate: Minors in stories

[PeterGibbons]

Many of the truth or dare stories, if not most, involve characters who are under the age of 18. I can't help but wonder what type of person would take delight in reading, or writing for that matter, stories about two boys/girls having sex with one another because of a game of truth of dare. So I ask the question, do stories with underage characters encourage a pedophile friendly environment on getdare? If so, should action be taken against stories which are essentially sex stories involving minors?

And for the record, I am simply calling this idea into question. I have not stated any actual opinion or encouraged any course of action. I simply am seeking a debate on if these types of stories are appropriate for getdare.

What do you think?

[Is Niet]

This issue actually came up in the Supreme Court a few years ago - are stories depicting sexual acts between minors a violation of the law or not. The official ruling was that they are NOT in fact in violation of the law so long as they are entirely fictional stories. So in that sense, there doesn't seem to be reason for action to be taken.

As far as stories involving minors, there are a great deal of minors on this site. For obvious reasons, the majority of all things sexual to be found on the internet - stories, movies, etc - are told from the perspective of adults. Especially in the case of someone who is 13 or 14 years old, as many of the stories seem to be written about, people online at that age might be curious about these sorts of things in context to themselves, not in the context of 25 year olds. This probably contributes a lot to the stories written about underage people - they are written BY underage people.

Again, even if an adult writes a story about sexual activity between to children, it's not really pedophiliac behavior until he actually goes out and commits a physical act. Who knows, maybe the fantasy stories online are enough to keep someone with strong physical attraction to children at bay.

Just some thoughts of mine.

[Dice7]

Ive been thinking the same thing for some time Peter. Personally I think something should be done to change things like that here. I know a site that was shut down by their service provider for having pedohilic depictions on their site. It turned out those depictions were jus storys like the ones we have here.

At the end of the day a story about 14-15 year olds written by a 15 year old is all fine and dandy, but a story about 14-15 year olds written by a 45 year old pretending to be a 15 year old isn't and could be used as grooming.

[applebooty]

I personally think it depends on the age difference. I don't see a problem with an 18 or 19-year-old with, say, a 17-year-old but once said 19-year-old starts in on a 12 or 14-year-old then I agree, it gets gross. Perhaps you could put in a request that requires younger characters to be within two years of each other. (13 & 15, etc.) That will at least clean it up a bit.

As there are a lot more of the younger kids on here than I thought, it wouldn't be fair to completely eliminate stories depicting sex involving teens.

[Dice7]

Whats fair isn't the point.

It wouldnt be fair for any of the adults on here to be investigated by the police for viewing 'pedophilic' content because a 14 year old wanted to write an unrealistic story about a 12 year old fucking a 14 year old..

Theres rules about how old you can be to be a slave, but personally I think those rules should extend to how old you should be to sign up for the site, to protect the older members of this site.

[applebooty]

Originally Posted by Dice7

It wouldn't be fair for any of the adults on here to be investigated by the police for viewing 'pedophilic' content because a 14 year old wanted to write an unrealistic story about a 12 year old fucking a 14 year old..

I missed the part where anyone said that was going to happen. Writing a fictional story in a forum is rarely going to lead to anybody being investigated by the police.

[cheesy dude]

We have younger members on here too guys. Stories are for fun and lots of them bring this site traffic. Addmittedly not as much as the S/M section but younger members can't post there.

So dont think it matters. Just a reminder.

[dared to perfection]

honestly whilst reading through the stories i completely ignore ages of characters and tend to imagine all in their late teens. IF a story was written depicting 50 year olds throughout the story my imagination will have the image of someone much young and vice versa.
IF it bothers you then do as i do

[interesting]

Despite the possible legal ramifications, which I am utterly unaware of in terms of storytelling, I think stories are best left to the discretion of their author. Some of the stories in here, I personnally find offensive, whether they be fiction or not. The issue of offensiveness is one that is not pertinent here, at least according to me.

As to the age of the characters, bear in mind that for fictitious stories, they are just that, fiction. It may be bad taste, it may even be wrong, but we can't regulate content more than we do. Every other story in here is about some form of perversion or another, and I think some of these perversions can be more destructive than sex itself, but again, that's up to the writer/reader.

That's my two cents.

[fun-dave]

i think that minors in storys should only be if your are telling of something that happened to you personally in a passed dare maybe explaing your first dare or first experiense.

but it has to be kept tasteful

we all have imaginations here and we will imagine as far as we personally wish so people should only hint towards were things go and let people decide in there own minds what happens.


the best storys on here are the least sexually graphic

thats my opinion anyways

[urlilslave080]

Hey guys well i thought id throw in some of my knowledge on this first of all, as depp as clearly stated in the rules, stories are to state weather they are fiction or non fiction. I am 19 and currently writing about a 16 year old boy is a slave to 16 and 17 year old girls, that doesn't mean i want to sleep with 16 and 17 year olds it just means for the type of story i have written 16 year olds and 17 year olds are better suited for this story. If a story clearly sates fictional then no legal issues can pop up as its fake it doesn't matter who wrote it or who reads it, and through my knowledge at least 80% of stories are fictional. As for non-fictional stories if someone wrote about a 30 year old having sex with a 15 year old then they would have to be pretty stupid because then that would just arouse suspicion BUT if a 30 year old wrote a story about 2 15 year olds having sex thats non-fiction that doesn't mean he is a pedo, it might be a story about when he was younger. So you have to take in all the facts before you start kicking out people from this site because they are too young or too old. If a story pops up that is really inappropriate then a getdare staff member will delete it obviously. So stop arguing about who's right or wrong and start taking in the facts.