[Fiction] My Sister’s Dare with Consequences

[jklivin]

Better and better with each chapter, especially interactions between siblings

[AnalAriana]

Juat like McDonald's "I'm loving it"

[Thorimo]

always stopping on a point when we need more.

a great story.

[Trucker28]

Originally Posted by jklivin

Better and better with each chapter, especially interactions between siblings

Thank you, I am still trying to work out the kink(s). Hopefuly I will have more soon.

[jklivin]

I'll be waiting patiently

[Trucker28]

“Your dare is to compare Harry to Brandon.” She held Harry out to Emma.

“So I’m the first to get naked? I don’t think so,” I interjected.

“You have the option to change it,” Emma said hopefully. I wasn’t exactly sure what she was hoping for.

I thought for a few seconds. “I’ll do it but Emma and I go to the bathroom alone and she has to have at least one less items of clothes than when she danced for me.”

“AAH, Sara and I want to watch,” stated Rylie.

“Speak for yourself,” my sister said, “I’ll agree with it.”

“Well then they need to be in there naked for 3 minutes,” Rylie added.

We all just sat there in silence for a second. “Well, go on,” Rylie finally got us moving shaking the hairbrush in Emma’s face. Emma took the brush.

Emma and I stood and started toward the bathroom. Rylie jumped up, stopped Emma pulling her close, and whispered in her ear. Both girls giggled. We had a first floor bathroom that was small with only a toilet and sink. I couldn’t ever remember having been in it with more than one person and I now knew why. After I followed Emma in, I had to squeeze against her just to shut the door. It was really small.

I took my shirt off placing it on the counter and she followed her arms bumping my chest because she was shorter than me. I started to drop my shorts; I had to lean over near her shoulder. I was thinking that I should have picked a better room. She had not put her shorts back on so she was just wearing the yellow bra and panties.

“Which do you want me to take off?” she asked bashfully.

“It’s up to you, I want to see it all,” I replied. I knew she was embarrassed of her small tits but she didn’t know I had already seen them on sister’s phone and even more often on my own computer. I was really hoping for her to lose the panties even though it would be tough to see anything standing so close to her. “You don’t need to be so shy, you are absolutely gorgeous.” I said looking into her eyes. I couldn’t help myself I put both hands on the sides of her head, leaned into her and gently kissed her cheek. “I owed you one.” I whispered. She just stared for a second then rose up on her toes and kissed my lips.

“We’re not starting the time until you tell us your holding is penis!” Rylie hollered from the hallway definitely listening right outside the door.

She slipped her thumbs in the sides of her panties and slid them down her legs. Her head brushed my boxer covered erection as she bent over to remove them. She stood back up and looked me in the eyes again. I kissed her lips again. Screw them, we’ll take our time, I thought. I whispered, “You do it.” Her eyes gleamed as she knelt down in front of me.

She brought her hands to my waist and gently pulled my boxers down my erection pushing against the fabric. When the waist band began sliding down my shaft her eyes widened and her smile grew. She pulled quicker and my dick popped up almost smacking her chin. She pulled away just in time, giggling. She used one hand to gently stroke me.

“Are you touching it yet?” Rylie asked.

“Yes,” Emma purred, “It’s nice.”

“Ok, I’m… starting… the… time,” Rylie said slowly, obviously dragging it out.

“Just start it!” Sara exclaimed from the hallway.

When I was completely hard Emma picked up the hairbrush and held me. The end of the handle against my abdomen and the back of the brush against my cock. The entire brush was about two inches longer. Compared to the handle I was longer and thicker. She set the hairbrush on the counter and wrapped her hand around my shaft. I reached down and gradually lifted her so she was standing facing me again. I pulled her close, she continued to stroke me, the head of my cock against her flat stomach. I kissed her again more passionately this time letting our tongues intertwine.

With one hand on the back of her head the other slid down over her taut ass. Then I moved it around her hip and slid over a light peach fuzz of pubic hair, so blonde I hadn’t noticed it before. She pulled her mouth away letting out a startled breath when my fingers pushed against her wet pussy lips.

“Are you OK?” I whispered, not wanting to let the girls outside hear.

She nodded, smiled, and kissed me again.

Just then Sara yelled, “Time!” Someone tried opening the door which I hadn’t locked. Luckily the door wouldn’t open because it hit my ass.

“Hey! Stay out!” Emma screamed. Talk about moments lost.

We both bent down to grab our underwear at the same time bumping our heads. “Sorry,” we both said at the same time laughing. We stood there for a second. Emma was looking down at my dick again.

Her fingers went to a small birthmark I have below and to the left of my bellybutton. “Oh My God,” she said, “You two are so busted.”

Crap, I thought, she recognized me from the picture. I tried to play it off as if I didn’t know what she meant. “What are you talking about?”

“Don’t worry,” she said, “You will know soon.”

Eventually we managed to get dressed and leave the bathroom. The girls gathered together giggling. I realized Sara had gotten a ruler, probably from her room. They were holding it to the hairbrush and Emma was pointing out where I measured up. I thought she was being pretty generous so I didn’t argue.

After the giggling and whispering died down. Emma seemed to be more eager to take charge. “How about we slow down a little and do another round of truths? We are getting kinda crazy.”

“I like where this is heading, I’d rather keep doing dares,” Rylie said suggestively.

Sara came back, “I think we can do truths for around.” I was pretty sure she thought she was saving herself from an embarrassing dare but she was stepping into Emma’s trap.

“I have been enjoying the dares,” I said, “but it’s your game.”

Sara did not wait for more discussion, Emma had agreed with her, so she went after Rylie, “I want to hear about your most embarrassing moment.”

“You already know my brother saw me naked,” Rylie replied.

“I think there’s more to the story,” she pressed.

Rylie hesitated a second, looking at Emma like what do you know? Then she finally started her story. “I was home watching my little brother, Skyler. Our parents were at a movie or something. Skyler had went to bed already and I was watching a movie and I was starting to get a little horny.”

“What movie?” Emma interrupted.

“I don’t remember it was a few years ago.” Emma just stared at her. “Fine, it was one of the Twilight movies OK?”

The girls laughed. “As I was saying, I was getting horny so I went to take a bath. I guess I forgot to lock the door. I was in the tub and the hot water felt really good. It also felt good to lift my hips out of the water. You know the cold air feels good too. I started masturbating and then…”

Emma interrupted again, “How were you doing it?”

“Just rubbing my clit with my fingers and lifting my hips out of the water every so often. I had my eyes closed and didn’t hear him come in. Skyler was just standing over me. Staring down at my vagina. My boobs were not this big yet. I tried to cover up and yelled at him to get out. He started to cry and ran out of the room. Later I felt bad because it wasn’t his fault. Luckily he never told my mom what he saw.” She finally stopped talking.

“Wow that’s pretty hot,” Sara said and Emma agreed.

“How long do you think he was watching?” asked Sara.

“I don’t know my eyes were closed.”

“Does you’re your brother have any porn or girly magazines?” I asked.

“Eww gross! Why?” Rylie responded.

“Because if he doesn’t, YOU are going to be his masturbation fantasy for the next few years.”

Emma and Sara giggled.

“Oh God No! He wouldn’t do that, would he?” she begged.

“Unless he’s gay I’m pretty sure he already has,” I said. “Hell, I wasn’t even there and I’m going to use it.”

The girls laughed even harder.

When the laughing finally quieted down Emma jumped in again, “Good truth Rylie, Sara now it’s your turn. Tell us the TRUTH about the boy you jacked off last week.” Emma looked at me when she was speaking to Sara. I’m guessing it was for effect, to show that she knew the truth.

[jklivin]

Fantastic chapter, humiliation couldn't get any better coming up so looking forward

[Trucker28]

When the laughing finally quieted down Emma jumped in again, “Good truth Rylie, Sara now it’s your turn. Tell us the TRUTH about the boy you jacked off last week.” Emma looked at me when she was speaking to Sara. I’m guessing it was for effect, to show that she knew the truth.

“What!” My sister gasped, “I already told you!” Emma looked and me with a sneer. She had a ‘What did you tell her!’ look.

I just shrugged.

“Then, how does the guy YOU jacked off have the same birthmark as Brandon…and the same dick?!” she exclaimed.

Sara looked more horrified then when she had to tell me about her hairbrush dildo.

“Wait, you jacked off your brother!” Rylie cried, “You said you didn’t want to do anything sexual with him and you have already given him a hand job!”

“Fine!” Sara yelled, “It’s your fault, he saw the picture you sent me. Then I only had an hour to find a guy. All of his friends were busy… I didn’t have any other choice… I didn’t want to have to lick your pussy.” She was stammering now.

“Oh my God! You showed him my picture?” Emma was upset now, she reflexively used her arms to cover her chest.

Rylie was the only one laughing. “You guys are crazy!” she cried, “Incest and dick picks. How long did you stare at his dick that you could recognize it?”

Emma and Sara were glaring, still furious at each other. Rylie was laughing and loving it.

Finally Rylie tried to get the game going again. “OK you two just relax, it’s still Sara’s dare. Tell us about your first hand job.”

“Damn it!” she said. Then she went into her side of the story. “After I decided to get it over with, HE,” she emphasized, “said I had to take off all my clothes. So we got naked and I jacked him off.”

“Come on,” Rylie prodded, “You can give us more. How did it feel?”

“I don’t know hard but soft at the same time. It was so much bigger than the little guy Emma played with.”

“So, did you like stroking it?” Rylie asked again.

“It was just weird at first. I liked it better after I used the lotion, it got all slippery. Then it got really hard and I knew something was going to happen, then it all squirted out. That was gross and messy.”

“It was on her chest,” Emma snickered.

“And her cheek!” I had to add. The girls laughed again.

“You got a facial from your Bro!” Rylie howled.

“I hate you guys!” Sara bellowed.

“Oh, come on, we’re just having fun!” Emma replied.

“Yeah Brandon, is cumming on your sister fun?” Rylie asked turning Emma’s words around.

When the girls finally settled down I decided I had a question I wanted answered. “So, for my fifth question, you were kind of wet and horny after our fun. Did you masturbate when I left, and did you use harry?”

“No,” she replied, “It was in the bathroom and you were in there cleaning up.”

It was silent for a second. Then Emma said, “You avoided the first part of the question. Did you masturbate after?”

Sara silently nodded her head looking defeated.

I knew it.

“I’ve got a question, but it’s for Brandon. Would you answer a truth?” Rylie asked me.

“I guess, why not?” I replied. I figured she was going to ask if I enjoyed it.

“Did you actually call any of your friends to come over?”

I couldn’t help but laugh, “Hell no! Why would I hookup one of them with my sister.”

Sara glared at me, “You’re such a perv!”

Emma and Rylie’s laughter started up again.

Sara quietly stewed for a minute before telling in Emma it was her turn. “Tell us all about who you jacked off.”

“Oh…” she wasn’t expecting Sara to ask the same question. “I promised him I wouldn’t tell.”

[jklivin]

What a treat to come up to, fantastic as always

[AnalAriana]

Can't wait for more!!!

[lynx247]

Great cliff hanger ending

[kuber2014-getdate]

Thanks. Please post next part soon...

[naked_lego]

Another great installment. Can't wait for more!

[idgaf123]

Cummy eggs?? Lol

[lynx247]

Found your story and just had to go back to the beginning to read it all, well written and leaves you just like the girls gagging for more.

Cant wait for the next chapter keep up the good work.