Inspection
His cock is really small and almost unnoticeable when soft. It gets a lot bigger when hard but I've still seen much bigger. 5/10
His body is plus sized a lot which doesn't help with his tiny penis. 3/10
His face is pretty average, not ugly but definitely not the most appealing for me. 5/10
his butthole looks really tight and looks like you can't put anything in it. He needs to stretch that hole a bit more. 2/10
Overall, 3.75/10, he's got a decent cock when hard, but when soft, he looks pretty useless.