I've seen plenty of people put effort and thought into stories and not get much or anything in the way of feedback compared to the number of people who read them. I know writers love constructive criticism but the most common criticism I see is people complaining that stories aren't finished or updated regularly enough.
The star system can be abused, but if most people are respectful and give positive star reviews and post honest criticisms or DM improvement ideas, I'm sure the writers would appreciate it.
|